martes, 1 de septiembre de 2009
Aristotle
Sometimes staying in the middle is better. For example when a teenager is about to eat, it has a lot of choices for developing his nutrition; he has the choice of eating a lot and suffering of obesity or not eating at all and suffering an eating disorder like anorexia or bulimia. But these aren’t all his choices, he can also chose to have an equilibrate diet, and to do exercise regularly so that he would avoid each of the past choices and stay in the middle between both, transforming into a good well being that care about his own health. Also he would develop the capacity of choosing the best between different choices without somebody help him (reasoning).
Aristotle (roots of wisdom) said that our goal should be to avoid extremes of behavior, and rationally choose a way of moderating (the middle between extremes) also called golden mean. He also believe that happiness is one of our most valuable positions, so if you stay away from extremes you’ll be choosing to be happy, so you will be reaching another virtue called reasoning.
He also said that our moral is based on the circumstances that surround us, like the things we live, the people around us (friends, family, teachers, etc), but most because of our experiences (practice); this is what transforms us in good or bad persons. (roots of wisdom).
*Socrates*
Socrates thought that ideas already exist in our minds and that a skillful questioner brings to consciousness what we may not even realize we know.
Imagine you have a super party this Friday, but you get punished and you are not allow to go out until the next week.
Is Friday night, party’s night! Your mother trusts you and tells you that she is going to go dinner with your father, and she is going to arrive late.
WOW! Is a mega party, everyone is having fun. It is 12 o clock, you think you must return home. So you ask for a ride. You arrive to your home, being quiet, put the stink cloth in the washing machine.
Mother: what did you do yesterday night? -I only watched TV
Mother: but the TV is broken, are you telling the truth? - Sorry , I get confuse, I got sleep all night.
Mother: I have a doubt, why is your formal clothes in the washing machine? -Because I mess them accidentally.
Mother: with what? -with soda
Mother: and why you were drinking soda? -A friend come to , I mean yes, but I heard him.
Mother: you went to the party right? -Ohm, yes, sorry.
Bibliography
http://antisyphus.typepad.com/photos/uncategorized/detective.jpg
Mitchell, Helen Buss. Roots of Wisdom. Socrates. Belmont, CA. Thomson, 2008.pgs 28-30.
Parmenides
In my opinion he is right. There isn’t the void. Void is also a space that we consider in our universe. For example in the universe, we know there are black holes, and we considered them as void. But are not these holes considered as something in the universe, like planets or stars. We know they are there. How can we define void?
The absent of matter, but for me this absent of matter, this empty space is a part of this big puzzle we call reality and universe. For me, universe is a big puzzle and void is part of we puzzle and if we make this puzzle there is no empty space in reality.
Buddhism
Anaximander
Anaximander
When you come to school, you always sit on the same place. There is not a teacher behind you carrying you to your place. You do it, because there is already an order. You already know where you have to sit, you know you can’t be over someone else. As you enter the classroom you move directly to one place, right? Like once in a while you change, but without disturbing the other ones.
This is the same with the universe according to Anaximander. He thought that the world didn’t need to be supported by anything to be. He thought that the universe had its own balanced positions.
Anaximander also thought that we all came from a substance, he believed that we came from something so complex and so simple at the same time. He thought that we came from something infinite and/or boundless. The infinite for him it’s something endless like a cycle.
An example would be life. First you are born, you live your life. You get older, you become wiser. After all that you have kids, then grandsons. As your age rises your body gets weaker and weaker. At the end you die. It’s a cycle, because another kid has been born, when you are dying someone else is giving birth. It is boundless, no limits.
Bibliography:
http://history.hanover.edu/texts/presoc/anaximan.htm#Intro
Plato
Plato like Socrates, believed most of us live in ignorance most of the time, but the worst of all is that we don´t even know we are just seeing a shadow of the real world.
In his dialogue Republic he show us the allegory of the cave, where the main point is that the visible world is the least knowable and the invisible world is the most intelligible. He says we must rely on our reason rather than in our senses, opinions or feelings.
An example for the cave allegory could be when you are about to do an exam, the teacher told you that he is going to put a math problem that you had already solved before. The day of the exam arrives, you see the problem but you don´t remember how to do it, so what Plato says is that you have to try to solve it (trusting on your reason) instead of putting what you barely remember, what you can see from your exam´s classmate or how others told you the math problem could be solved (trusting on your senses, opinions, etc.)
Bibliography:Mitchell, Helen Buss. Roots of Wisdom. Belmont, CA: Thomson, 2008.
Posted by: Daniela Orona Calleros.
Democritus: atoms and void
Abril Castillo
Sophists
Have you ever been to a political meeting? Politicians just talk and talk and talk about what they are going to do. But are they really going to do something? The truth is that politicians are great orators, and they have an extraordinary capacity to convince people trough speech; however the convincement is rarely for the content of their ideas, but for their enthusiasm and rhetoric.
When politicians (some of them) give a speech they start talking about a subject and they can go on and on for hours because they know how to create coherent sentences and make it look like they know what they are saying. But if you asked them 5 minutes after they finished what where they talking about, and what did they promise, they would not remember half of the things they said.
In the last political campaigns we all watched politicians promising, they were everywhere, on tv, on the streets and even knocking on your door. What the actual politicians do is what sophists thought Greek politicians to do more than 1500 years ago. Sophists believed that since there is no one universally appropriate way of doing anything then there can be no absolutes of any kind, everything is relative. For them appearances are reality and “man is the measure of all things”. Sophists promised success to those that had the required tuition ($$) and were disposed to work hard on the science of rhetoric. So I infer that Political Sciences teach rhetoric, therefore politicians use the same techniques they did 1500 years ago.
Some famous sophists were Gorgias and Protagoras, the last one was the one that said that “man is the measure of all things”. Nowadays to be called a sophist means that you are all flash and no substance (hmm hmm politicians).
Anaximenes
For example, I imagined Anaximenes watching what a horse does in a normal day. He may have seen the horse drinking water and he may have concluded that water was something basic in our lives, but that it wasn’t necessary to drink it the whole day, just at some hours.
He may have noticed that unlike water, air is something that we need all the time. Every single second we need to get air from our environment to stay alive, even though we don’t think about it.
This is the way that Anaximenes may have thought that air is the origin of everything and that we are all air. I would like to say that this wasn’t the way Anaximenes concluded his theory. I’m just imagining how it could have been.
Bibliography:
Mitchell, Helen Buss. Roots of Wisdom. Belmont, CA: Thomson, 2008.
Posted by Rocío del Mar Cruz López.